The Super Essay Brainstorm: 15 Questions to Unlock Your Story

Staring at a blank page is the hardest part of writing your college application essay. You know you've done incredible things over the past four years, but how do you distill a lifetime of experiences into a single, cohesive narrative?
Before you start writing, you need to start digging. Here are the essential brainstorming questions you should ask yourself to unlock the content for your "Super Essay."
What I Did (Day-to-Day)
When we write our resumes, we often summarize our experiences into broad strokes. But the magic of a great essay lies in the details.
- Did I list all my tasks, or just a few? What did I forget? Go back and check.
- Did I list things I did that may have been outside the scope of my responsibilities? (Sometimes the most impressive work you did was the work you weren't asked to do.)
- Did I leave off any awards? Any uncommon achievements?
Problems I Solved
Conflict is the heart of any good story. Admissions officers don't just want to know what you did; they want to know why it mattered and what obstacles stood in your way.
- Did I consider the internal problems I solved? Were there any personal challenges or mental hurdles I had to overcome?
- Did I name the external problems I solved? Did I solve problems for my friends or family? My school? My community?
- Was I tackling a much larger (perhaps global) problem?
Lessons I Learned & Values/Skills I Developed
An experience is only as valuable as what you take away from it. This is where you demonstrate maturity, self-awareness, and a willingness to grow.
- What were some of the soft skills I learned? (e.g., patience, communication, empathy, leadership).
- Did I learn any specific hard skills? Software like Photoshop or Final Cut Pro? Languages like Spanish or C++? Survival skills like how to start a fire or clean a fish?
- What am I better at now than I was before?
- What would I have done differently? (Admitting imperfection is a superpower in essays).
Impact I Had (On Self, School, Community and/or Society)
Colleges are trying to predict what kind of impact you'll have on their campus. The best predictor of future behavior is past behavior.
- Did I consider the impact this had on my family? Friends? School? Who else benefited from my work?
- What impact did this have on me personally? Did this change my life or my perspective? How?
Applications to Other Parts of School/Life
The best essays connect the dots. They show how a lesson learned on a soccer field translates to a debate podium, or how learning to bake bread made you a better chemist.
- What skills did I develop and lessons did I learn that will make me a better [X]? (e.g., tutor, debater, advocate, volunteer, programmer, etc.) How so?
- What did I do to build on and take what I learned to the next level?
- What surprised me about this experience?
Take a few hours, sit down with a notebook, and answer these honestly. You might just find your Super Essay waiting for you in the answers.
Want this taught, not just read?
A free 30-minute diagnostic and a real baseline test — we’ll tell you honestly where you stand.
Keep reading.
All posts →Stop Doing Things Just for College: Why Authenticity is the Ultimate Hook
The real reason you were rejected wasn't your SAT score or your GPA. It was because you were boring. Here's why authenticity matters more than prestige.
How to Write the Perfect Waitlist Love Letter (LOCI)
Your Letter of Continued Interest might be the most important thing you write this year. Here's a complete, step-by-step guide to crafting a LOCI that gets you off the waitlist.